Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Welcome to the Charlie Tango DX Group. The home of ALL things Radio - CB, 11m DX, Amateur, PMR446, PLD, Network and Data. We welcome all radio enthusiasts of all knowledge levels. Join today and claim your own unique World Famous CT Call-sign
Join in with the fun of the Charlie Tango DX Group Summer 10m Challenge - from April 1st 2024
Call Sign : 26CT100 Posts : 235 Times Thanked : 14 Join date : 2019-06-25 QTH or Location : North Yorkshire Equipment Used : Emperor Shogun, Delta 318 Export, TYT380, Albrecht 2990AFS, SS3900 Age : 40
Subject: PMR446 - Radio Tests and Review Sat Jun 27, 2020 6:30 am
Are you pondering getting some walkie-talkie radios, but don't know which would be the correct radio for you?
Looking for the correct model of walkie-talkie can be troublesome and confusing if you are new to the hobby or have never used one before. I have gathered some walkie-talkie radios together , with the hope that you can choose which radio s right for you. I will only mention certain radio specifications which are considered most relevant to novice users
Most people who are looking to buy handheld radios for leisure use don't want to have to obtain a license to use them so I will stick to legal radios which no license is needed.
There are various components you have to consider for something as little as a walkie-talkie. There are a few models available on the market and the prices can vary a lot for radios with very similar features and specifications and clearly you would prefer not to squander cash on a walkie-talkie radio that doesn't fit your needs or indeed over spend on one due to the brand name.
Here is a few I have personally used and found to be great value for money and worked better than I expected for legal radios. I will outline the key features and good points of each radio.
Motorola Talkabout T82 Extreme PMR446
What I like about these...
Range up to 10km. Tested at 6KM in semi built up area. no problems
16 PMR Channels
License-free plus no call charges
Pack includes 2 radios, lanyards, earpieces and carry-case
Weather proof (IPx4)
Vibrate alert + integrated torch
Baby Monitor Function
Power 0.5w
Long battery life
Easy to use
Well made with
A lot of radio for your money
Feels expensive
Ideal for camping, hiking, festivals or indeed hill top DXing with being waterproof
You get two radios in a pack
Available at Amazon.co.uk
Qniglo Rechargeable PMR Radios
What I like about these...
Range up to 10km. Tested at 6KM in same setting and worked great
8 PMR Channels
License-free plus no call charges
Pack includes 2 radios, two rechargeable battery packs and Micro USB charge cable
Simple and easy to use
Hands Free VOX function
1500 mAh batteries, good capacity for a 0.5w handheld
Long battery life
Ideal for car to car communication, more suited to indoors or dry enviroment
Cheap price because the brand isn't as well known
Available here to buy
Retevis RT45 Plus
What I like about these..
The are a great all rounder
Matches the distance of the Motorola despite claiming to be much less.
Tested at 6KM in semi built up area and nice surprise
Rugged design and good build qualty
Supplied with rechargeable batteries
16 Channels and 99 privacy codes
Torch, VOX
Battery saver function
Easy to use and nice clear display
Feel more expensive than they are
0.5w
beltclip
USB charge
Ideal for indoor and outdoor but not waterproof
Cheapest of the three
Features of much more expensive radios
Can be bought here
Three different radios, very different prices, exact same radio power and similar features. Although I like all three of these radios, my opinion is that the RT45 are the way forward. They look like they could have been made in the same factory as Motorola and share similar build to much more expensive radios. The range of all legal PMR radios with fixed antenna and standard 0.5w power tend to be about the same when tested in the same settings. The Rt45 does not claim 10KM like the Motorola, in fact they claim under 3KM but in tests they worked just as good as the other two radios. The battery packs on the Qniglo radios are a nice touch and feel quality. Its a shame the RT45 radios dont have similar self contained, high capacity battery packs but then we must remember That they are not as costly. The Motorola radios have an edge over the other two in terms of overall build quality and accessories which are included and i guess they should considering the price..but they only just do it. Performance is so so close its hard to tell them apart.
So, if you fancy trying some hill top DX on PMR, save yourself some cash and go for the RT45. You get two for £34 and you wont be disappointed with how they work or indeed if you broke or lost one at that price. Perhaps upgrade the batteries if you plan on heavy use would be my suggestion.
I hope this helps anyone looking for their first PMR radio.
Pagan, Alan - Mirror Man and Dave Johns like this post