Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Welcome to the Charlie Tango DX Group. The home of ALL things Radio - CB, 11m DX, Amateur, PMR446, PLD, Network and Data. We welcome all radio enthusiasts of all knowledge levels. Join today and claim your own unique World Famous CT Call-sign
Join in with the fun of the Charlie Tango DX Group Winter 11m Challenge - from December 1st 2024
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 10:53 am
Hi All, Yep that age old question.......... Which antenna should I buy?! I am particularly interested in continental DX and would like to participate in some of the local Nets if indeed there are any around here.
I don't want anything too big to begin with (Don't want to scare the neighbours!) so I've been looking at the Sirio Signal Keeper, the Sirio Dipole and the Boomerang but which is the best antenna out of those three for my needs given the restrictions i've imposed upon myself? If i'm honest I think I might have trouble accomodating the ground planes on the Signal Keeper in the location where I want to install the antenna so what are my options. Ideally a straight vertical would be ideal but i daren't do that to begin with!
Back in the 80's and 90's I had a Thunderpole III which I thought was great so something that performs similar to that would be great. I remember it being particularly good for working the continent when there was an opening.
Any and all thoughts very much appreciated.
Kind Regards
Lynton
Ace likes this post
Alan Pilot Major contributor
Call Sign : 163-CT-220... Posts : 2657 Times Thanked : 70 Join date : 2019-11-19 QTH or Location : Anglesey North Wales Equipment Used : Yaesu FT-991A,,Yaesu FTDX-10,,Icom ic-7610,,Anytone AT-D878UV PLUS",,LINCOLN II+. Age : 16
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 11:15 am
The old Silverrod or Antron-99 but are they too big. Not that well up on todays cb antennas but will watch this to see what others suggest.
Lynton likes this post
Sharpshooter Major contributor
Call Sign : 163-CT-329 Posts : 489 Times Thanked : 13 Join date : 2022-04-05 QTH or Location : Deeside, Flintshire Equipment Used : A growing list
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 1:17 pm
Is that the Sirio SD 18' dipole your thinking of ?. Where are you thinking of mounting them ? Ie, balcony, loft, side of house, garden shed. I have no experience of any of these but it may help others advise you.
The signal keeper seems a pain to swr. See towards end of video.
https://youtu.be/DXgxGlyps4c
You could start with a temporary setup like fred in the shed here,
https://youtu.be/wUT1yeAF0Lw
Then move up to a more permanent setup like fred does in other videos.
Lynton likes this post
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 2:19 pm
SharpShooter, It was the Thunderpole Super Dipole I was looking at. Sorry I got that wrong when I said Sirio. I'm going to use a wall mounted pole on the side of the house but I don't want the antenna to be above the gutter by more than a few feet. Because of that I think the sloped roof of the house will get in the way of the ground planes on the Sirio Signal Keeper. The dipole or boomerang won't have that problem but the lower element will be close to the brick wall so that may well affect the SWR and almost certainly the performance.
Thank you for those Youtube links. I'll take a proper look at those later when I have some peace and quiet!
Thanks
Lynton
Victor CT Directors
Call Sign : 26-CT-3228 / M7VIC Posts : 6292 Times Thanked : 389 Join date : 2019-11-10 QTH or Location : Bedford Equipment Used : Various
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 2:55 pm
Hi Lynton,
When the "Skips a Running" you can get away with the proverbial piece of wet string and make contacts at CB frequencies.
Any antenna at that point will seem the best thing since sliced bread because you don't have anything to compare it to.
If you can only get away with a small antenna then any antenna is better than no antenna but I think you'll be disappointed with a small one. (Small antennas work best atop a car that can be driven to the top of the highest hill which is much easier than the amount of poles you'd need for the same effect at home!....Especially the flat land of Peterborough. )
The dipole you mention is a half wave so would be as long as a half wave end fed such as a 'Silver Rod' but the latter will perform better and be much easier to mount. (On the end of a pole, whereas the dipole needs to be mounted away from the pole on a boom arm or some such.)
(Edit :- Just saw your comment about 'gutter height'.)
Up to you in the end and your circumstances but 'bigger' & 'higher up' always works better for a homebase setup.
All the best, Victor
(I know sometimes 'big' antennas can be problematical such as when dealing with Parish Councils/Neighbours which was why I turned to Ham radio and the common horizontal antenna which is much easier to hide! )
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 7:50 pm
Victor, Thanks for the reply! I'm having fun researching all of this stuff and hearing back from you guys. I definitely need to start small and gently gently work my way toward something bigger so will probably have to "make do" for a start. Given the setup I had around 30 years ago I think some disappointment is inevitable but even so I want to do this.
Lynton
skyrider Major contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4654 Posts : 367 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2022-09-25 QTH or Location : Preston, Lancs. Equipment Used : UNIDEN 100, midland alan 78 plus multi + mag mount , silver rod Age : 64
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed Mar 29, 2023 8:33 pm
i really miss my electronica special i wish i had it now
Lynton likes this post
Victor CT Directors
Call Sign : 26-CT-3228 / M7VIC Posts : 6292 Times Thanked : 389 Join date : 2019-11-10 QTH or Location : Bedford Equipment Used : Various
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Thu Mar 30, 2023 6:29 am
No worries Lynton and I wish you the very best with it all.
I only mention because the antenna is undoubtedly the most important aspect of radio being the object you actually transmit and receive from. The best transceiver in the world will not work very well with a poor antenna but a basic radio with a good antenna will work wonders.
Lynton likes this post
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Fri Mar 31, 2023 12:52 pm
Hi All, Well in the end I figured out a way to accomodate a Sirio Signal Keeper! If it performs anything like the Thunderpole III antenna I had in the early 90's i'll not be disappointed. I'll now wait until after my eye operation and for the weather to get better before fixing up my shiny new antenna.
Have a wonderful day everyone
Lynton
Red Rooster LN-4614 likes this post
Willow New Member
Call Sign : 108-CT-323 Posts : 6 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2021-06-26 QTH or Location : Irvine, North Ayrshire Equipment Used : XIEGU G90. 1/4 wave vertical mobile and 11m efhw at home
Subject: Thunderpole Tank Whip. Wed Apr 19, 2023 8:14 pm
I use this, damned decent full quarter wave stainless steel whip. About 9ft tall. Thin and robust. https://www.thunderpole.co.uk/large-cb-antennas/thunderpole-tank-whip.html
Lynton likes this post
Deltawhiskey220 New Member
Call Sign : 26-CT-4852 Posts : 43 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2022-12-04 QTH or Location : London Equipment Used : Harrier cbx ,stalker 9,superstar 360 Age : 54
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Sun Apr 23, 2023 7:42 am
Hi I was in the same boat about antennas and was limited to size because of my wife... As Victor said bigger the better and as high as you can get it . I started off with smaller antenna and wasn't happy and wished I had got a 5/8 th wave so in the end that's what I got..should have just got it to begin with live and learn eh...
And talking of thunder pole lll i have one in the shed in its box... All the best lee
Lynton likes this post
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Thank you for your reply DeltaWhiskey220. Yeah i'd love to have the bottle to just go ahead and stick up a 5/8 wave but I figured i'd better go small to start with and work my way up! I actually now have a Sirio Signal Keeper and a Sirio Boomerang A. I am tempted to go ahead with the Boomerang as that is larger. Annoyingly the Boomerang came packaged minus a couple of M6x12 bolts which I am now going to have to source from B&Q or some other hardware store.
Regards
Deltawhiskey220 likes this post
Deltawhiskey220 New Member
Call Sign : 26-CT-4852 Posts : 43 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2022-12-04 QTH or Location : London Equipment Used : Harrier cbx ,stalker 9,superstar 360 Age : 54
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Mon May 01, 2023 4:19 pm
How have you got in with the antennas???
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Mon May 01, 2023 4:42 pm
Hi DeltaWhiskey, Well I put up the Sirio Signal Keeper this past weekend and likely will put the Sirio Boomerang A next weekend since we have another long bank holiday weekend. I did have another set of brackets on the wall for a small antenna but took those down when that antenna became redundant so will find those in the shed, fix them back up and put the Boomerang on those. You will notice the brackets and pole for the Signal Keeper are way over the top, well that's because that pole originally had a Band II FM antenna on a rotator fixed to the top!
Lynton
Samurai27 and Deltawhiskey220 like this post
Deltawhiskey220 New Member
Call Sign : 26-CT-4852 Posts : 43 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2022-12-04 QTH or Location : London Equipment Used : Harrier cbx ,stalker 9,superstar 360 Age : 54
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Tue May 02, 2023 12:36 pm
That's look good. How is the antenna doing?? You had any skip with it yet
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Tue May 02, 2023 7:12 pm
DeltaWhiskey, Yep i've heard plenty of skip but deliberately haven't tried to make any contacts. I'm first waiting to see if any of the neighbours knock at the door claiming the antenna is interfering with their TV even though i'm not transmitting! I've no reason to think that anyone is particularly bothered what I'm doing and my neighbours are fantastic people but I've always been a little cautious when it comes to having a new antenna. These days we're far less likely to breakthrough a TV in any case I think but no harm in being cautious. I'll give it another week or so then try a few calls...................
Regards
Lynton
Deltawhiskey220 New Member
Call Sign : 26-CT-4852 Posts : 43 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2022-12-04 QTH or Location : London Equipment Used : Harrier cbx ,stalker 9,superstar 360 Age : 54
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed May 03, 2023 7:07 am
I was cautious about how high I had my antenna at first and I had to keep the wife happy... She don't care now (result).. I don't think interference is anything like it was years ago TV has gone digital now.. I remember my mum in the 80's when I was on ssb telling me she could here me when she was using the landline telephone ... All the best lee
Lynton likes this post
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Wed May 03, 2023 6:54 pm
Lee, Ha yes best to keep our partners happy! I do think I'm being over cautious but better that way I think. Good DX and maybe I'll have the pleasure of speaking to you on air at some point.
Cheers
Lynton
Deltawhiskey220 likes this post
Rufus1969 New Member
Call Sign : 26-CT-4392 Posts : 8 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2022-01-05 QTH or Location : Medway Equipment Used : Radio
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Fri May 05, 2023 3:57 pm
Willow wrote:
I use this, damned decent full quarter wave stainless steel whip. About 9ft tall. Thin and robust. https://www.thunderpole.co.uk/large-cb-antennas/thunderpole-tank-whip.html
How have you got this mounted, as a homebase antenna?
Deltawhiskey220 New Member
Call Sign : 26-CT-4852 Posts : 43 Times Thanked : 0 Join date : 2022-12-04 QTH or Location : London Equipment Used : Harrier cbx ,stalker 9,superstar 360 Age : 54
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Mon May 08, 2023 7:57 pm
Just thought I would let you know a thunder pole lll has just gone on ebay .. All the best Lee
hawk657 and Lynton like this post
Lynton Contributor
Call Sign : 26-CT-4805 Posts : 56 Times Thanked : 2 Join date : 2023-03-28 QTH or Location : Peterborough, UK Equipment Used : President McKinley EU or K-PO DX5000 plus + Thunderpole Galaxy 5/8 or Full Wave Delta Loop. Age : 53
Subject: Re: Antenna recommendations? Tue May 09, 2023 7:43 pm
Lee, Many thanks for that. I think my missus will go nuts if I get any more antennas!